‹ Back

(Fantasia Fest 2026) GODHEAD Almost Gave me Faith In Religious Thrillers

By. Michael Fairbanks

 

Religious horror is amongst the most cynical and lazy variations of the genre. They can usually only imagine some variation on possessions and exorcisms, all knock offs of William Friedkin’s The Exorcist. Mark H. Rapaport's GODHEAD, which had its world premiere at the 2026 Fantasia International Film Festival, finds an intriguing new angle. Here, a preacher with a rather strange disposition must face down two delusional zealots who demand that he answer an impossible question. While it is hamstrung by the limited scale available to it at the microbudget level, Rapaport’s screenplay does allow us to soak in these characters’ mania and hypocrisy. 

Our unnamed preacher (Al Warren) lives an isolated and paranoid lifestyle with his son (Luke Speakman), who is not allowed to do much of anything besides read picture books about the bible. One day, two twins enter the church. Firstborn (Sarah Coffey), the more dominant one, demands that the preacher decide which of the two of them is the reincarnation of the holy spirit and kill them, thus releasing it from human form. The preacher’s heart immediately sides more with the mentally handicapped secondborn (Kimball Farley), who seems to be strung along on this holy crusade without fully understanding what is going on. He has no desire to go along with this but upon seeing that the twins cannot shoot themselves with the loaded gun they brought, realizes that there might be something to this impossible quandary. 

Fantasia has always championed filmmakers with big ideas and limited budgets. If GODHEAD intrigued you with its unconventional take on religious horror, check out our review of DANCE FREAK, another microbudget Fantasia standout that swings even harder for surreal, cosmic nightmare territory.

GODHEAD is at its’ best during this lengthy initial confrontation. It is a classic setup where we watch a seemingly normal interaction escalate into something depraved. The dialogue is well wound and all three leads perform perfectly. Coffey is the particular standout, bursting with conviction as she spews out this insane mission. Warren’s performance opens up a bit later on, once the layers of his hypocrisy become a bit more apparent. The black and white aesthetic also serves this sequence well. It feels as though we have entered a church from another time, perfectly setting the stage for a potential religious event that could become holy text itself someday. 

However, that promise isn’t really delivered on. This starts to lose steam in the second act and totally buckles in the third. Midway through, the preacher confronts each of the twins individually in his car outside the church. Nasty revelations come out about the pasts of all of our players, interspersed with some eerie flashbacks. However, all of what we learn only truly figures into the story for shock value. Something nasty to talk about. When it’s time for the climax to take shape, we’re treated to a couple of underwhelming impulse choices and then one big reveal. It’s just not enough to pay off the patient set-up.

Given the resources available to it, GODHEAD is an intriguing piece. Mark H Rapaport certainly has strong conceptual chops that I can envision being pushed further someday. If this had been able to be as trippy and existential in style as it is in substance, it could’ve been revelatory. As is, GODHEAD is just a reminder that faith based thrillers have so much untapped potential.

Want to keep exploring Fantasia's lineup? Read our review of ATTACK ON PARADISE, a gritty action thriller proving the festival has as much room for bruising shootouts as existential horror.